PS3 vs. Wii vs. 360: Which Console Downloads Games Fastest?

[wraggster]

We pitted the three major consoles against each other, to see which one can download games the most quickly. “Mega Man 9” — at least initially — was the guinea pig on our XBox 360s, Wiis and PS3s…
***
I’ve long suspected that my Nintendo Wii is a slowpoke.
All three of my consoles are connected to the same WiFi signal, one the emanates from my landlord’s apartment a floor below mine (we split the bill). When I download games and demos, they always seem to take longest on the Wii.
This past weekend, I convinced Patrick and Tracey here to help me test my theory.
We started with “Mega Man 9,” the only game available for download on all three systems.
I ran the rest first, at 8pm EST on Sunday. I did one at a time. These were the initial results:
-Mega Man 9 demo downloaded and installed on PS3: 142 seconds
-Mega Man 9 demo downloaded on Xbox 360: 345 second
-Mega Man 9 game downloaded on Wii: 27 seconds
Weird numbers, right?
I checked the size of these games. The PS3 and 360 list the size of their gaming content in megabytes. The Wii lists sizes in “blocks.” To figure out how big the Wii version was, I transferred “Mega Man 9″ onto an SD card, put the SD card into my computer and read the file size.
Here are the sizes:
-Mega Man 9 demo, PS3: 63 MB
-Mega Man 9 demo, Xbox 360: 88.7 MB
-Mega Man 9 game, Wii: 8.3 MB
As you can see, Mega Man 9 is not the same size on all machines. In fact, it’s wildly different in size. But we can still figure out speeds and see if my Wii is as slow as I think it is.
Such a discovery calls for some long division, which yielded the following results:
-Mega Man 9 download speed on PS3: .44 MB per second (1st place)
-Mega Man 9 download speed on Xbox 360: .26 MB per second (3rd place)
-Mega Man 9 download speed on Wii: .31 MB per second (2nd place)

http://multiplayerblog.mtv.com/2009/...st/#more-18341

[inlovewithi]

It really annoys me that an 8-Bit game, with 8-Bit graphics, which would have been anywhere from 256kb to 1mb if it were a Nintendo cartridge is a 8mb download, much less a 360mb download. I hate clutter, and I could also use any space I get on my 20gb 360.

Watching youtube videos or just browsing the internet on my Wii is just as fast as it is on my computer, but this article makes it seem as if... fud.

[mib_]

WTF? you can't draw ANY conclusions if that's the testing methodology.

If you need to measure the performance of a device, you need a controlled test environment.


At the very least, you have to use the same sample data across all three platforms.



This article should be deleted. It's potentially misleading rubbish.