I commend you on doing a review. A few things though. You didnt include a "Gameplay" or "Sound" category. Those two should definately be in there. According to your review, we know what to expect before the snap of the ball, but nothing afterwards. How does the passing game feel ? How easy is it to run the ball. Is the defense AI hard, easy, etc.
The only other thing I see, according to your scoring, is that your scores average out to an 8/10.
I will be picking the game up Friday evening, so I'll post my review once I've spent a few hours with it. If its ok, I'll just post it in this thread, rather than making a new one.
Please dont take my criticism the wrong way. I am just pointing out things that help people make that choice to either buy the game, or not.
Bookmarks