Question? Is Sirius Black really dead?

[elleeeeeeeen]

but what was that veil?!? its obvious serious is dead. but what happened with his body...

isn't it obvious that the veil represents death and "the beyond" or whatever you want to call it? I believe that the veil is some kind of metaphor for that...

and also, sirius pretty much has to be gone. Bellatrix used AK, right? as dumbledore said, no spells can reawaken the dead... To me, it seems pretty straight forward. although it is kind of fun to speculate, I think that he's a goner.

[paddfoot2]

Of coarse he's dead, he fell into the veil. Dumbledore calls this the death room(or somthing simalar) so i think that this used to be used for exicutions. Plus in the film he gets hit with Ak, Jk would have stoped them doing that if he wasn't realy dead.